top of page
BBC Under Fire As Antisemitism And Bias Allegations Rock Broadcaster
2024-02-06 (293)
A BBC scheduler who made racist comments on social media, including referring to Jews as Nazis and denying the Holocaust has been sacked. The BBC took its time firing the employee, and concerns have been raised about a culture of bias and antisemitism within the organization.
Jewish employees have expressed fear and discomfort working at the BBC, and there are allegations of biased reporting on Israel's conflict with Hamas.
Stephen Silverman from the Campaign Against Antisemitism, and former BBC producer John Mair, both joined Kevin O'Sullivan and Alex Phillips on CrossTalk.
Video Transcription:
scheduler Dawn quavas referred to Jews
as Nazis described the Holocaust as a
a hoax and called white people
parasites it comes as Jewish employees
at the corporation say it is a grim and
frightening time to work there joining
us now is Stefan Silverman director of
Investigations and enforcement at the
campaign against anti-Semitism and
former BBC producer John Mayor thanks
both of you uh for joining us uh let's
go to you first Stephen, I thought I
mean this this woman daor Quaver I mean
what she was putting out on social media
just disgusting racism I mean
extraordinary that she should ever have
been there in the first place in
fairness to the BBC they didn't muck
around three or four days and they
sacked her uh so she's a racist uh with
a few of these ludicrous tropes about
Jewish people and white people she's an
equal opportunity hater uh we're the
virus Jewish people are Nazis and so on
absolute nonsense but what really
worried me here Stephen was that
a Jewish employee at the BBC said in
response to Dawn the Dawn quava Saga
bearing in mind this is the corporation
that refuses to call Hamas terrorists
and has been accused of a definite uh
favorable slant towards uh against
Israel uh uh this employee said that
this is a grim and frightening time to
work at the BBC that's extraordinary
isn't it
it is extraordinary and and it comes
on the back of British Jews having long
been made to feel uncomfortable by their
perception of bias in the BBC's coverage
of matters relating to Israel since the
atrocity that was committed by Hamas on
7th of October uh that plaster has been
ripped off the wound it's become
manifestly clear that the BBC has an
Institutional problem with Jews and
Jewish issues and you know if you go
back to last last November Danny Cohen
who is a former director of BBC
television um made the statement that
the BBC um was institutionally
anti-semitic now the problem is
manifesting itself in three separate
ways firstly firstly there has been a
constant drip of BBC employees openly
engaging in deeply anti-semitic rhetoric
D Quaver is just the most recent in an
ignominious list and if people want to
see more they can look them up on on our
website secondly there is a very clear
bias in in the BBC's reporting of
Israel's war against Hamas in which
Israel is being painted as a brutal
aggressor with complete disregard for
the fact that this is a war that Israel
is fighting in order to defend its
citizens against the repeat of October
the 7th the BBC's reporting is actually
inflaming anti-Semitism on the streets
and then finally the BBC has a real
problem with its refusal to take action
against high-profile employees who use
their celebrity to promote biased views
to a vast social media following John
I'm I'm going to come to you now um I
mean the talk of BBC bias that continues
to haunt the BBC and I can well imagine
as with all and sunry that gets sucked
into the culture wars and turned into a
binary choice that most UK news rooms
probably do very much lean in One
Direction that might make somebody feel
that if they were Jewish somewhat
unwelcome or at least
disqui by conversations they hear at the
water cooler but I think perhaps one of
the biggest problems with the BBC I'm
reading some of these reports of some of
the views being openly expressed by
staff working in international newsrooms
what should the BBC be doing about this?
the charge sheet isn't it from from
my friend on the other side um I feel
like I'm intruded on the private grief
here after after the r I've just
witnessed but however look the system
worked didn't it the BBC has 22,000
employees is some of them will be
loonies some of them will be loonies to
go on to Facebook this woman went onto
Facebook and you know what she got
caught up at the knees so fox has been
shot has been shot there um I would
advise you to actually read the guardian
today there's rather good analytical
piece about the BBC's CNN's coverage of
um of the Gaza War I mean it does seem
to me that there was a strong
journalistic question to be asked about
reporting o o of the Gaza War it's all
been seen from the side of Israel Israel
has not allowed any reporters into Gaza
now that is just plain disgusting you
know you can't have a war in which only
one side is reporting so and where where
is the BBC bias you know when when when
the culture sector appeared the other
day on Good Morning Britain was asked
bias she she on Sky News she she was
lost for word so John are you saying
that the BBC doesn't have a problem here
John John John are you saying that the
BBC does doesn't have a problem here in
terms of it slant against I don't know
have a problem I don't know does the BBC
have an anti-Semitism problem I don't
think so you know
somebody I mean I think Danny Danny
Cohen has become a "Rent to go" he really
has he he pops up.. Dan Cohen's a "Rent to go"
former head
ATC1 a Jewish man
he is a "Rent to go" stand by that you're G
to call him a "rent to go" I am yes really
really
in what way is he a "Rent to go"? look as far as I can
see from the reporting of of the Gaza
War it's been straight down the line and
SE all right John thank you let's go
back to you Stephen this is just
outrageous nonsense isn't it I agree
it's absolutely Through the Looking
Glass to say that this war is being
reported from Israel's point of view
look at what happened with the um
reported bonding Hospital early on in
this conflict that was completely
inaccurate uh the BBC rushed to judgment
and then when Jeremy boen was
interviewed about it he admitted it was
wrong and he said he absolutely had no
regrets so BBC had to issue another
apolog apology apologize reported that
Israel that the IDF was deliberately
targeting Medics look the BBC uses her
stats with minimal qualification
all it does is it says that stop talking
over John all BC ever does is reports
stats as um from the Hamas ran Ministry
of Health that that goes no way to
actually explaining what those
statistics represent it doesn't explain
when it reports on the number of
fatalities that that number includes
around 10,000 Hamas terrorists that
Israel has murdered sorry has has killed
it doesn't include um the fact that a
very large number of rockets directed at
Israel from Gaza misfire Landing Gaza
killing gazans and those numbers are
included in the fatality statistics it
doesn't include the fact that Hamas
kills gazan civilians for resisting them
or for trying to follow Israel's
instructions to leave an area that is
about to be targeted the BBC just takes
her masses position on these things
without qualifying it properly and it
paints Israel as an aggressor in a war
in which Israel is trying to defend
itself against a genocidal level of
anti-Semitism that has not been seen
since the Second World War uh Stephen
and John thank you very much we're gonna
have to move on thank you John thank you to
Stephen
bottom of page